Blast from past : Da vinci code Indian version

रामायण महाभारत भारतीय लोकांच्या मनातच रुजलेले आहे अशी समजूत आहे. त्यात सुद्धा राम आणि रामायण ह्यांचा पगडा थोड़ा जास्तच आहे. बॉलीवुड पासून स्थानिक लोक-कला पर्यंत सर्व ठिकाणी रामायण आढळते. रामाची महती अशी सर्वत्र कशी पोचली ह्याचे आश्चर्य सर्वच विद्वंजनाना वाटते.

लेखकाने प्रस्तुत विषयावर फार रिसर्च केला आहे. रामाची पोपुलारिटी वाढली हा एक योगायोग नसून तय मागे एक मैनेजमेंट तत्वज्ञान आहे. जाणकार वाचकाना ठावुक असेलच की वल्क्मिकी महार्शिनी रामायण लिहून ते पोपुलर केले, पण त्यानंतर तुलसीदास ते समर्थ रामदास पर्यंत अनेकानी तो वारसा पुढे चालवला. पण हा योगायोग मुळीच नव्हता.

कोणत्याही संघटनेला जर आपले विचार लोकांमध्ये रुजवायाचे असतात तर सर्वप्रथम ते विचार लहान मुलांमध्ये रुजवायाचे असतात हे वल्मिकिनी ओळखलेले होते. त्यानी तर साक्षात् रामाच्यां मुलानाच गीत रामायण शिकवले. राहुल प्रियांकाचे बोबडे बोल जसे सर्व चैनल्सवर दाखवले जातात तसे लुव कुशच्या गीत-रामयाणाला सुद्धा भरपूर प्रसिद्धि मिळाली. रामावर पब्लिक प्रेशर अला व सीतामातेला रामाच्या महालांत पुन्हा प्रवेश मिळाला.

ज्या धोब्याच्या प्रचारामुळे रामाला सीतेला सोडावे लागले त्याचे नाव होते रजक. रामाविषयी त्याला घृणा होती व त्यामुळेच त्याने तो विषारी प्रचार केला होता. त्याने गुप्त रुपातुन संघटना बनवली होती. वाल्मीकिनी हा डाव ओळखुन तो आधीच हाणून पाडला. राजकाने ते फार मनाला लावून घेतले व वल्मिकिला त्याच्याच चालीने मात द्यायचे ठरवले. वाल्मीकि सुद्धा हे ओळखुन होते. त्यानी सुद्धा आपली एक गुप्त संघटना उभारली.

राजकाने तेव्हा पासून लहान मुलाना बडबड गीतांच्या मार्गाने आपले तत्वज्ञान द्यायला सुरुवात केलि. (चाणाक्ष वाचाकानी ओळखलेले असेलच की लेखकाने ह्या विषयावर फार रिसर्च केला आहे). ह्या संस्थेने आपली मुळे फार खोल वर रुजवलेली आहेत. विदेशांत सुद्धा ही संस्था पोचली आहे. आज आपण आपल्या मुलाना जी बालगीते शिकवतो ती सर्व बालगीते ह्याच संस्थेने बनवलेली आहेत (अणि आम्ही बनत आहोत).

येरे ये पावसा तुला देतो पैसा…ही लाचखावु वृत्ती शिकवणारे बालगीत निरागस आहे का? तो पैसा सुद्धा खरा द्यायचा नाही, ‘पैसा झाला खोटा’ ही तर खोटारडेपणाची परिसीमा आहे. हे बालगीत खरे म्हणजे आपण आपल्या मुलाना शिकवू नयेच.

नाही म्हणायला तुकाराम रामदास इत्यादि गरीब व पावरलेस मंडळीनी वल्मिकिची परम्परा चालवायचा अतोकात प्रयत्न केला.पण बिच्यार्यांची भाषाच एवढी बोजड की लहान मुलाना पाठ करायला ते कठिन जावू लागले. लव व कुश ही हुशार मुले होती, आश्रमात त्याना इतर काम धंदे नव्हते त्यामुळे त्याना गीत रामायण पाठ झाले. आताच्या मुलाना तुकाराम थोडेच समजणार ? तरी सुद्धा शाळा मास्तरांना ( हा एक निरुपद्रवी प्राणी असतो, कुणीही ह्याला हाताला धरून आपले काम साधतो, शेजार्याची प्रेम-पत्रे, सरकारचे नसबंदी धोरण, जनगणना इत्यादि अनेक कामे तो पार पाडतो) हाताला धरून दासबोध पाठांतर स्पर्धा वगैरे भरवुन ह्या मंडळी चे साहित्य रद्दीत जाण्यापासून वाचवले.

आता आपण इंग्रजी बालगीते बघुया. Jack and Jill Went Up the hill हे एक सुप्रसिद्ध बालगीत आहे. जैक हा तरुण मुलगा व जिल ही नुकतीच वयात आलेली मुलगी (बघा: चित्रमय बालगीते ऑक्सफोर्ड प्रेस) डोंगरावर जंगलात का जातात? पर्वतिवर जाणारे जोडपे नक्की कशासाठी जाते? सांगितले जाते की विहिरीतून पाणी काढायला गेले, पण विहीर कधी डोंगरावर असते का? आता जैक खालि पाडला की त्याला जिल ने धक्का दिला? दिला तर जैक ने असे काय केले म्हणुन त्याला धक्का दिला? मुलांची कोवळी curious मने ह्या प्रश्नाची उत्तरे शोधल्यावाचुन राहतील का ? इथे काही तरी पाणी मुरते हे त्यांच्या लक्षांत नक्कीच येईल.

नन्हें मुन्ने बच्चे तेरे मुठ्ठी में क्या है ….. हे बालगीत आहे कि सेक्स एडुकेशन चा धडा आहे ?

London bridge is Falling down हे आणखिन एक बालगीत. एखाद्या आतंक-वाद्याचे कृत्य असावे असे हे बालगीत कोणी लिहिले हे Interpole किंवा F.B.I. ने शोधून काढायला पाहिजे. कदाचित त्यातून ओसामा रजक धोब्याचा वंशज तर नाही ना ह्या विषयावर प्रकाश पडेल.

baba blackship have you any wool मी सुद्धा हे बालगीत पाठ केले होते. हे बालगीत वर वर निरागस वाटले तरी सुद्धा हे लक्षात घ्या की ह्यातील शीप हे ‘ब्लैक’ आहे व इतर तिघे ‘white’ आहेत. ह्यातून नकळत वर्णद्वेषाचा संस्कार मुलांवर होतो.

Johny Johny Yes Papa ह्याबद्दल जास्त बोलण्याची गरज नाही. साखर खायची व नंतर हाथ वर करायचे हा गुण जो राज-कारणात शिरलेला आहे त्याचे मुळ असल्या बालगीत-मध्ये आहे.

मराठी पुरते बोलायाचे जाले तर ‘गोरी गोरी पान’ ह्या गीतात वर्ण-द्वेष तर आहेच पण त्याशिवाय जे काहि आहे त्याचे रूपांतर सविता-भाभी सारख्या websites मध्ये झालेले आहे. मुळांतच भावाला आवड आहे त्यापेक्षा भाभी आणायची आवड ह्या मुलाला जास्त दिसते.

राम ही एक प्रवृति आहे व रजक ही एक प्रवृति आहे. रावण ही सुद्धा ही एक प्रवृति आहे व त्या प्रवृतिचा विरोध करणे सोपे सुद्धा आहे. पण रजक ह्या प्रवृत्तिचा विरोध करणे फार कठिन आहे.

टीप : लेखन विनोदी आहे. मनाला लावून घेऊ नये.

एपिलॉग :
२०१६: पैसा झाला खोटा ह्या निरागस(?) बालगीताची परिणीती (मराठीत : consequence ,चोप्रा नव्हे) मोदी महाशयांनी पैसा अक्षरशः खोटा करण्यात झाली. मोदी महाशयांनी पत्नीचा त्याग केला असला तरी वाल्मिकी सारख्यांच्या त्याचा गैर फायदा घेऊ नये म्हणून मुले निर्माण केली नाहीत.

२०१७: लंडन ब्रिज वर खरोखर हल्ला झाला. केले काळी “भो पंचम जॉर्ज भूप हा” अशी प्रार्थना जगभर मुलांना म्हणायला भाग पडणाऱ्या ब्रिटिश सत्तेच्या केंद्रबिंदूवरच हल्ला झाला. राजकाच्या दूरदर्शी नेतृत्वानेच हे शक्य झाले.

 

 

Tu kisi rail si gujrati hai, mein kisi pool sa thartharata hoon

Above lines are by celebrated Indian poet Javed Akhtar who also is a part time intellectual with an opinion on everything. The image is taken from ScoopWhoop.com which has a title “These Poignant Shayaris By Javed Akhtar Are An Absolute Treat For Your Heart And Soul”

What I see in those lines is Dil, Badaal, Dard, Tanha, Duniya, Ghabraya and a shitload of words that have been used for last couple of centuries by a boatload of poets of colors a hues. These words are so overused that the term “cliche” was invented to describe them. They are as much of a treat to soul as a Parle-G biscuits dipped in shezwan sauce.

But this is the poetry that gets passed off as “great poetry for soul”. Damned be those souls. People who pen these downs will be called to give off awards and will comment on how younger generation does not appreciate poetry.

Kabir 

Kabir was an ordinary man. Man with probably no education nor reputation or money. He wrote simple words. Probably considered a mad man by his neighbours but immortalised by his poetry.

hqdefault.jpg

Rough translation: Everything happens at its own pace. Does not matter how much you water plan, it will bear fruits only when the right season arrives.

Now that is something my grandmother would say when I failed for the n-th time. That is simple, completely relatable and yet contains a wisdom that has accumulated over time. That is why Kabir the destitute will probably be immortal while no one would remember Javed Akhtar.

Love of an ordinary person 

When I was in teens I  have done things I am not very proud of but as a consequences I got much deeper look into  minds of ordinary folks and teenage romances. The engineering college hostel romance might be fueled by the songs penned down by Javed Akhtar but no Romeo thinks on the romanticized lines like “aasoo palko pe aya…” and all that. They often drink beer and find solace in the curse words.

The real world romances do not run on the fuel of dreams about moons and palaces, analogies about flowers and birds. They are about aspirations of meeting that person after school. They are about finding private time in the middle of city or a corner of a park.

People on street do not have vocabulary of JNU grads. They have simple terms but they are capable of love in all the forms that it comes.

Tu kisi rail si guzarti hai
Tu kisi rail si guzarti hai
Main kisi pull sa.. thartharata hoon
Tu bhale ratti bhar na sunti hai
Main tera naam budbudata hoon
Kisi lambe safar ki raaton mein
Tujhe alaav sa jalaata hoon
Tu kisi rail si guzarti hai
Main kisi pull sa.. thartharata hoon

This is a lyrics by Swanand Kirkire that immediately struck a chord. It is about a guy in polytechnic trying his luck with a girl. They do not meet in Kashmir’s orchids but at durgapuja. The guy has a face that is as forgettable as the last taxi driver you had seen.  The girl is as ordinary as the one you have ignored in a crowd.

Yet the universal feeling of missing a heartbeat when she passes by you is expressed in the words ordinary people would understand. After all Javed Akhtar might not have travelled by trains and might not have felt how the bridge vibrates as the train passes on it.

In last decade the elites of the entertainment industry have gone farther and farther from reality. That is why newcomers strike a chord.

While many struggle to understand why Sairat becomes a runway hit, I find it very easy to understand. The ordinary man on street does not aspire to have Deepika or Katrina as their girlfriends. The one they like is like Archie and they themselves are as crude as Parshya.

For many sensibilities Sairat might strike as far to crude, not a polished romance of Rahul and Simran not as gracefully tragic as that of Vasu and Sapana ( Ek Duje Ke Liye).

Note: I am not a literary critic. My beef with main stream entertainment is that how detached it is getting from real Indian people on streets!

 

Rare opportunity for Canconcars to redeem themselves

IIT-Goa is a once in decades opportunity for Canconcars to welcome this non-polluting large scale product that will put Cancona and Loliem on world map.

There is no other project as environment friendly has educational institute. There is no other project as lucrative as a government institution for jobs and secondary occupations. If a mere Medical college can transform Bambolim into a growing city IIT-Goa can transform Cancona into a thriving and livale urban area instead of pathetically backward region.

One needs to have IQ of a rock or moral fortitude of a toilet brush to oppose this project. Most of the opposition comes from the back that the project benefits someone else more than the opponents. This crab mentality (cliched term but cant find anything better) has kept the region poor for last 50 years and if sane people do not stop them in their tracks now opportunity for developing Canacona might be lost forever.

Property Rights

The more dangerous trend in the Goan villages is the false sense of entitlement for other people’s land. It is not just poor uneducated folks but even otherwise well meaning people like Rajan Parrikar who claim that Goa must be kept green forcibly because they love to see it green. It does not matter what the owner of that land thinks.

Contrary to what media paints the land of IIT-Goa does not belong to community or village. It belongs to a legal body called communidade. This body which has 100% ownership rights has wholeheartedly supported the project.

Ideally if there is rule of law in country this is where the matters must end but there is in thick and constant smoke screen being created that the rest of the village as any say in how communidade maintains its own lands.

Of course just because land belongs to party A does not mean party A can not interfere with the rights of Party B. If party A’s land has ground water, if it contributes to tributaries of major water streams etc. etc. Party A’s choices might affect entire village and in such situations party B consisting of such affected individuals could raise objections.

But democratic vote in a gram-sabha can not possible solve this technical issue. It must be left to the government organization which is acquiring the land and the government must be compelled to compensate all the affected people as well. In any case it is a technical decision needs to be take by government body and could be challenged in court if the affected parties are dissatisfied.

This process should not stop the government from going ahead with acquisition and setup all the bare minimum infrastructure that may not have any impact so far until the affected parties are satisfied.

 

 

 

Jizia Tax in Goa!

Jizia is a tax that Islamic governments impose on non-Muslim monoatheist people simply to let them live. Aurangezeb is called a merciful and great King by our leftist historians because he graciously let Hindus too live by paying this tax. Hindus being poly-atheists and idolators technically were not even allowed to live under Islamic rule.

Sadly the modern day so called “Independent India” has Jizia tax as a part of its constitution. Of course it is called something else. Depending on the context it is Article 30 (Special treatment to minority institutions), Right to Education (which is applicable only to Hindus) or 93rd Amendment (denial of autonomy to Hindu institutions).

This is not a blame game. This is not merely Nehru’s ghost haunting us. This is a carefully planned conspiracy where Congres, BJP and Hindu Hriday Samrat Modi, Manohar Parrikar etc. have played a very strong role. This is one Hamam where everyone is truly naked.

NPS is a very good chain of schools in Banglore. It was recently denied its CBSE certification because NMCEI filed an FIR against them and requested CBSE to withdraw its affiliation. NPS is a school chain run by a Hindu person. NMCEI is a body that by law can only have a non-Hindu as its head. So a non-Hindu body passed a judgement on a Hindu run school to basically shut it down.

The reason cites was that NPS forged some minority certificate. It must be noted that minority certificate is the single most important thing in Indian education today as those schools which don’t have a minority certificate lose all autonomy and come under RTE. Because (repeat after me) Right to Education law is applicable only to Hindu run schools.

While people make NPS forgery as a criminal offense totally ignore that a Church run school gets total exemption from all government regulations NPS is trying to avoid by default. There is no way NPS can compete with Church run schools (which even get taxpayer funding) without somehow calling itself a minority.

NPS is like a Hindu who is trying to pretend to be a Muslim to avoid paying Jizia tax. You cant blame him, you should blame the Jizia tax.

Goan Fiasco

Everyone is Goa wants to send their kids to English medium school. It is well known. As per Manohar Parrikar’s policy which is probably a result of some backroom deal with Church, only Church gets taxpayer money to start and run English medium schools.

As a result of this distorted policy by Manohar Parrikar, Hindus will have to spend lot more money if they want to start and English schools. Not just that Hindus are denied government grant which is provided to Church run schools, Hindu schools will also have to comply with Right to Education law. This means they have to keep aside 25% seats for free to Government approved students (read caste based reservations) and for remaining 75% seats too they have to admit students based on government provided criteria which may change from time to time.

A Hindu school may not be able to look at parent’s background before admitting their child for example.

I think Manohar Parrikar is the single person who must accept the blame here. At least the Goan Jizia is completely designed by him. Digamaber Kamat despite all his flaws had passed a uniform law which provided grants even to Hindu run schools. Manohar Parrikar implemented the discriminatory provisions.

Conclusion

I don’t like Congress party. I don’t like the Alemaos and Montserrats and Ranes and Faleiros. I think Parsekar/Parrikar did a good job of short term governance and reducing corruption.

But despite of that I think a swift punishment to BJP is something that voters must consider for this Jizia tax implementation. With BJP in power we might get better roads and better services but we have essentially lost control of our kid’s future. We have lost institutional control on educational institutions run at our own expense.

If this goes unpunished, BJP is likely to bend over backwards in future too.

For the record I do not support BBSM either. BBSM wants to use state coercion to force people into Marathi/Konkani schools. As a matter of principle I would not like that but as far as voting is concerned all faithful voters of BJP must consider BBSM as an acceptable alternative. They at least want uniform application of law.

Velingkar v/s RSS

BBSM in Goa demands that government should not give grants to English medium schools the way it gives these grants to Marathi/Konkani medium schools.

The logic ? English education will be more scarce and expensive and hence poor folks will be forced to send their children to marathi/konkani schools. This is basically BBSM using government’s power to coerce poor people into accepting BBSM’s agenda. This is not freedom this is cronyism.

But the other side is not bright either. At the moment all Church run English schools get government grants but the Hindu run English schools don’t. This is a clear cut apartheid against Hindu run English schools in the state.

If the current regulation continues then over time Church is likely to get full monopoly over high quality education in India as all rich and bright students are more likely to pick an English medium school over other schools.

Want more medal ? Stop wasting taxpayer money on IOC

US has been in top 2 spots in Olympics for over a century. US is a large country with lot of people and hence it is expected.

India on other hand has won only 25 medals throughout all Olympics. Michael Phelps is an American swimmer who has won 26 gold medals in his career. India is equally large and has three times more people that USA. Among those vast number of people it should not be very hard to find someone who can run faster, throw farther and lift heavier than others in the world.

Yet, every Olympics is a sad reminder that as a nation we are pretty pathetic in sports. Once the circus is over we will over-analyze our humiliation. One of the common conclusion would be that “Government is not doing enough”.

The reality is opposite. I think the reason Indians are not getting any medals is because our sports are controlled and funded by government. This needs to stop completely. Part of the reason Cricket thrives in our country is because government does not fund it and people are left to fund themselves.

People pursuing self interest do a better job than government trying to do the same thing.

It might come as a surprise to most people that the money US government spends on their Olympians is 0 dollars. None of those athletes get a penny from tax payers besides the existing public sports infrastructure. A lot of sports infrastructure in USA is built by private parties than government.

People who run USOC have to run to sponsors to get funding. The sponsors pay only if the USOC can convince them that they can win medals. To do a better job of convincing these USOC office bearers then have to travel the whole country finding talent and nurturing it.

Simone Biles is a 19 year old Gymnast and did a historic performance in 2016 Olympics. Given her age she will achieve even more in next one. She does not know who her father was. Her mother is a drug addict and probably rotting in some jail for various other crimes. She is adopted by her grandfather from a foster home.

People who run USOC are not some “great souls”. They earn more than any other athlete. They travel in private jets to venues. They probably know nothing about most of the sports either. But they earn that much because they do a fantastic job of finding talent from 300M American people.

On the contrary all sports federations in India are figuratively owned by some politician. These politicians then force government to fund their sport and the money is spent on his lavish parties and travel. Because even if he does not win a medal he still gets government funding.

I think Indian government must stop funding all the sports. The government must auction off the rights of IOC management to the highest bidder and promise to pay something like 50 crores for every Gold medal any athlete wins.

We will then see smarty pants like Lalit Modi using their talent to hunt best people to win the medals.

 

Are parents truly selfless ?

There is an interesting Akbar-Birbal story. Akbar once claims that for a parent nothing is more valuable then their child. Birbal disagrees. Birbal proposes an experiment where a monkey and her baby are put in a water tank. Birbal fills up the tank gradually. As the water reaches to the nose level of the baby, the mother monkey quickly picks up her baby and Akbar smiles smelling his victory. But as Birbal pours more and more water the mother tries to lift the baby higher and higher. Eventually the water starts enterning mother’s nose and the mother then puts the baby under her feet and tries to survive. Birbal wins the argument.

This story is from the period where there was no such thing has human rights live alone animal rights. May be the baby dies or may be Akbar’s soliders put both of them to death or whatever. The point is Birbal’s logic that people value their own life most is what matters.

In the real world

Even though parents are selfless towards their children than anyone else in the world, they are not self-less in the absolute sense. In fact the childhood teaching that parents give to their children such as “parents always wish best for their kids” is not really true.

When parents have only one child they do tend to pay hell lot of attention to that only child. But when parents have more children they always optimize for the welfare of some specific children over others. This means sometimes hurting interest of one child over other.

It is observed that in India, a girl child is often more malnourished, subjected to more household work and given less money to educate herself than the male child. It is extremely common that many times the girl does not even get a share in parent’s inheritance.

When parents have limited money for say higher education they will prefer their son over daughters. In fact if one child is smarter they might prefer to spend more money and attention on the welfare of that child over other.

Children as currency

Why is there so much taboo about inter-caste marriage, love marriages and sex before marriage ?

This question is not just applicable to modern world but we need to ask why we think of these things as bad historically ?

The real reason here is that we are biologically programmed to prefer our children over other people’s children. Contraceptives are modern invention. For thousands of years people did not know if the child they fathered was their own. (Historically speaking it is extremely common for women and men to cheat as a consequence it is estimated that anywhere between 2-5% of children are not of their legal parents and the ratio has actual dropped in modern times).

Virginity thus becomes and important characteristics in marriage. It improves the value of a female in marriage.

But then why hate love marriages ?

Reason is parents use their children to form alliances with other rich and powerful houses. Check the amount of background information people collect in arranged marriages in India. The salary of the groom to his real estate investments everything is calculated. While parent might pretend that they want the best for their children in reality they are optimizing for “family has whole” here sometimes by sacrificing interest of the child.

It is common for poor people to marry their young daughter into a rich house even if the groom is over-aged. This is a clear case of killing their daughter’s welfare for the sake of family.

Using the rhetoric to hide the facts

Why do traditionally we are taught to respect our elders ? Why are we taught to obey our parents without questioning ? Why are we told the stories of Rama and Shravana and others ?

It all ties into this. Parents want to use their children and yet want to make it look like a virtue.

But it is valuable too.

It must be noted that this isn’t bad at all. In fact the families who marry with planning, families where parents carefully optimise their children’s welfare tend to survive better than those where parents probably truly thought of their children as equal.

Human evolution has made us that way because it helped us survive. My attempt here is not to paint parents as bad people at all. On the contrary we owe our survival to them.

Conclusion:

Yet, when you might face a moral issue between making your parents happy v/s making your own self happy I think you are way better off picking yourself over your parents.

Also when you see kids questioning adults, being skeptical of adults etc. don’t think of them as spoiled brats on the contrary they might end up achieving lot more than you do in life.

It is not a co-incidence that people like Sambhaji, Samarth Ramdas, Ramana Maharashi, Buddha etc. achieved real greatness v/s mythical greatness of Rama. They all rebeled against their parents. (Of course bozo the clown might have done that too so correlation is not really causation).

Beer is freedom

I don’t consume alcohol. But this is fascinating video about failures of central planning aka socialism.

Venezuela is the world’s top oil rich country. Despite this the country is not just poor but pathetically poor. Venezuela’s malls are shut because they don’t have electricity anymore. You can not even buy a tissue paper and the only brewery in the country has shut down because it can not source the raw materials any more.

How come a resource rich country comes to such a situation ? The answer lies in central planning, the same model which has kept India poor.

Venezuela thought that it could pass laws that will ensure everyone is equally rich, where prices will be controlled and the government in its infinite wisdom could allocate all resources fairly among its people. Very much the same way some people do not want IPL in Mumbai while there is a drought in Latur.

The result was massive corruption, super inefficient allocation of rare resources and eventually a total collapse.

The lesson for India is that central planning does not work. Government controlling education, worse controlling only Hindu schools, capping fees, regulating coaching classes, AICTE’s terror etc only leads to massive inefficiency in Indian education. Indian education sector is pretty much like Venezuela. A wasteland where you cant get anything done and as a result 600,000 brilliant students flock to rest of the of the world for better education.

Same goes for agriculture and real estate. Indian farmer is poor despite having huge manpower, lots of free water and $$$$ in subsidies. Home prices in India are very high despite shittiest quality, almost non-existent private property rights and complete legal uncertainty.

All this because government claimed that “we need to do it fairly/poor must be protected” etc.

Free education or ceiling on fees also means scarcity of quality and ceiling on quality of education.

Subsidies to loss making agriculture means loss making agriculture increases driving people into poverty

Free water for agriculture means people don’t pay for the water they use and hence end up wasting more water.

Zoning laws and agricultural/non-agricultural conversion bans means land can not be used for the optimal purposes leading to scarcity and higher prices.

Beer is only an example.

Free speech is always absolute!

I think people calling “bharat ki barbadi” must have right to shout it as loudly as they want. It must be covered under free speech. The true test of free speech is when someone says something unimaginable to everyone else.

However, we don’t have to hear that speech or even fund them. JNU should have ideally simply rusticated the students who shouted those slogans and should have asked full refund of all the subsidies they lived on.

Sedition in India is a misused law. The so called nationalist BJP is perfectly find aligning with PDP in Kashmir for the sake of power and the paragon of Nationalism Mr. Modi is happy to hug PDP’s Mufti yet the students who opposed Afzal’s death end up in jail under sedition laws.

I have zero sympathy for JNU. I think it is a cancer feeding off our tax money and the whole university must be shut down. Not a penny of taxpayer money must be wasted on liberal arts education in this country when hardly any education in the country makes people employable.

But on the other hand the real issue that both Indian society and Indian state seems to lack basic principles on which they can argue their case. The left wing people and Idea of India people however have their agenda clear.

It is a tough battle and people like Modi seem not particularly equipped to fight it.